Sign inMy profileSign outJoin the CommunityWhat our reward systems encourage us to study – and discourage us from creating

I have served as my college’s representative on my university’s promotion and tenure committee for the past several years. That means I spend time reading the records of faculty members from disciplines far beyond my own. Historians. Artists. Writers. Scholars across the humanities, social sciences, sciences, and professional fields.
Reading those files has made me think differently about how we evaluate teacher educators. A poetry professor may be evaluated, in part, on poetry. An artist may be evaluated on art. A historian may be evaluated on the biography, archival interpretation, or historical text through which they contribute to historical knowledge. These products differ considerably across disciplines because the intellectual work of the disciplines differs.
That raises a question I keep coming back to: What is the corresponding scholarly contribution of a teacher educator? At research universities, one answer is overwhelmingly clear: Research publications. More specifically, the empirical article published in a sufficiently prestigious academic journal.
That answer makes sense up to a point. Teacher education needs rigorous research. But I increasingly wonder what happens when the research product becomes so central to the evaluation of teacher educators that the actual advancement of teacher education practice becomes peripheral.
At my own institution, as at many universities, promotion and tenure language is broader than “publish empirical journal articles.” Scholarship statements acknowledge creative contributions and scholarly products beyond formal journal publications. Books can count. Curriculum can count. Applied scholarship can count. Other intellectual and creative products can count.
So the problem is not simply that universities refuse to recognize anything else. The more important question is: What actually moves the needle? In the research expectations under which I work, meeting expectations has a comparatively clear meaning: produce a specified number of empirical articles in top-tier academic journals. That is the floor.
Other contributions may help demonstrate a record that exceeds expectations. A book may help. A curriculum may help. A major practitioner resource may help. A professional development program may help. A podcast reaching thousands of educators may help. An influential clinical model may help.
But “help” is nebulous. The empirical journal articles are what establish that the research expectation has been met. Everything else becomes additive. That distinction matters enormously. Because faculty respond rationally to incentives. If two top-tier empirical publications determine whether I have met the research standard, and a major curriculum project does not substitute for either one, I know where to put my time.
This brings me back to the poetry professor. The comparison should not be pushed too literally. Disciplines have different traditions, epistemologies, and forms of scholarly production. But philosophically, the comparison is useful.
The poet's poetry is not merely an object the poet studies. It is one way the poet contributes to the field. The artist creates art. The historian produces historical interpretation. Their scholarly or creative products emerge from the intellectual work characteristic of their disciplines.
So what would we identify as the characteristic scholarly contribution of teacher education? Surely research is part of it. But should it be limited primarily to research about teacher education?
Teacher educators might also: design a sophisticated clinical supervision model; develop curriculum used across teacher preparation programs; create a professional learning program for mentor teachers; build a school-university partnership model; design a protocol that changes how supervisors engage candidates; create materials that help new teacher educators learn the work; develop a pedagogy for teaching methods courses; produce a podcast that brings scholarship into conversation with practitioners; write practitioner-facing stories that make invisible dimensions of teacher education visible; create open-access tools adapted across institutions; or systematically study and improve their own teacher education practice.
Those are not peripheral to teacher education. They are teacher education. Yet our incentive systems can position them as supplementary to the “real” scholarly work.
The distinction I am interested in is not research versus practice. That binary is too simple. The more useful distinction may be between scholarship that examines teacher education and scholarship that also acts within, develops, or advances teacher education.
Consider a large-scale quantitative study of teacher preparation. It may identify important relationships across thousands of participants. It can challenge assumptions, inform policy, identify patterns invisible at smaller scales, or provide evidence about program outcomes. That matters.
Consider a qualitative case study examining the learning of several teacher candidates. It may reveal complexities in identity, pedagogy, experience, or professional learning that aggregated measures cannot capture. That matters too.
Now consider a carefully designed supervision protocol that changes the professional conversations hundreds of supervisors have with teacher candidates. Or a curriculum that significantly improves how candidates learn to reason about practice. Or a professional learning model that changes how mentor teachers understand their role. Or a teacher educator who systematically studies and improves the pedagogy through which they teach teachers.
Why does the article describing teacher education often carry clearer scholarly value than the intellectual work that actually changes teacher education? That is the tension.
I keep returning to the metaphor that teacher education research is our poetry. I do not mean our journal articles are works of art. I mean that scholarship is one of the forms through which teacher educators make intellectual contributions to their field.
But the metaphor becomes more interesting when we ask what the “poem” actually is. Is the poem the article? Or could the poem sometimes be the teacher education practice itself? The carefully developed pedagogy. The curriculum. The clinical model. The professional learning structure. The program design. The tool. The partnership. The way a teacher educator has learned to make professional reasoning visible to those learning to teach.
And perhaps the scholarship lies partly in making that work public, grounded, examinable, and available for others to critique and build upon. That begins to look much more like a scholarship of teacher education practice, rather than research simply conducted around it.
None of this is a particularly radical idea. More than three decades ago, Ernest Boyer (1990) argued that the academy needed a broader conception of scholarship than discovery alone. He distinguished among the scholarships of discovery, integration, application, and teaching.
The argument was not that rigorous inquiry should matter less. It was that intellectual work takes multiple forms. The distinction remains useful because many universities now employ language that reflects this broader conception of scholarship.
The difficulty comes when formal definitions are expansive but reward structures remain narrow. A faculty handbook can say that curriculum development is scholarship. A promotion document can acknowledge applied work. A college can recognize the scholarship of teaching.
But if satisfactory research productivity still depends on producing a particular number of conventional journal articles, then faculty receive a different message. The policy says: We value many forms of scholarship. The incentive says: Do those after you produce the things that really count. That is a powerful distinction.
This matters particularly for teacher educators because time is finite. Developing serious teacher education practice takes time. Building a sustained partnership takes time. Designing and iterating curriculum takes time. Learning to supervise well takes time. Creating professional development that responds to teachers rather than simply delivering content takes time. Developing open-access tools takes time. Participating in a community of practice takes time.
Writing for practitioners takes time. Studying your own teaching takes time. Making knowledge accessible outside the academy takes time.
If those activities are primarily supplemental while conventional publications determine whether research expectations have been met, the rational career choice is obvious. Research the practice rather than invest too deeply in doing, developing, documenting, and sharing the practice. Interview teacher educators rather than build a teacher educator professional-learning community. Study supervision rather than spend years developing a supervision model. Survey mentor teachers rather than devote substantial scholarly effort to preparing them. Study teacher educator pedagogy rather than open one's own pedagogy to systematic examination.
None of those research choices is wrong. The problem is the incentive structure that makes one route professionally safer than the other. We should not be surprised when teacher educators orient their work toward the things universities most reliably reward.
This creates a peculiar problem for a professional field. Teacher education exists, ultimately, to improve the preparation and continued learning of educators. Yet some of the people with the greatest expertise in that work operate within reward systems that encourage them to convert professional problems into research questions rather than professional contributions.
Find the problem. Study it. Publish about it. Move to the next study. There is an important place for that cycle. But another cycle is possible: Find the problem. Develop something. Try it. Study what happens. Revise it. Share it. Invite others to adapt it. Study it again. Build professional knowledge around the developing practice. That is also scholarship. And it is particularly appropriate to a field concerned with professional practice.
Imagine a teacher educator promotion dossier containing a category called: Contributions to Teacher Education Practice. The category would not be a repository for everything someone happened to create.
It would contain work that could withstand serious scholarly scrutiny. Curricula. Clinical tools. Teacher educator pedagogies. Supervision models. Professional learning programs. Open educational resources. School-university partnership designs. Mentor preparation models. Public-facing scholarship. Podcasts and media. Practitioner publications. Self-study and practitioner inquiry. Evidence that other educators have adopted, adapted, challenged, or built upon the work.
The evaluation questions would also change. What professional problem did this contribution address? What knowledge informed its development? What was intellectually original about it? How was it developed and refined? Who used it? What evidence exists of its influence? How has engagement with practice generated new professional knowledge? How has the work been made available for critique and use by others? Those are not weaker scholarly questions. They may be more demanding than counting publications.
Broadening what we value cannot mean declaring every professional activity scholarly. A worksheet is not scholarship merely because a faculty member created it. A podcast does not demonstrate impact merely because someone recorded it. A workshop does not automatically constitute an intellectual contribution. A curriculum is not significant simply because it exists.
The same is true in other disciplines. Not every poem transforms literature. Not every painting advances an artistic field. Not every historical text changes historical understanding. Products require evaluation.
For teacher education practice, we might ask about conceptual grounding, originality, rigor of design, iterative refinement, professional need, reach, adoption, peer examination, evidence of learning, transfer across contexts, and the knowledge generated through use. Glassick and colleagues' longstanding criteria for assessing scholarship – clear goals, adequate preparation, appropriate methods, significant results, effective presentation, and reflective critique – offer one way of thinking about such work. The point is not to make scholarly evaluation easier. It is to make it more faithful to the intellectual work of the field.
Teacher education already possesses methodological traditions capable of connecting scholarship with professional practice. Self-study of teacher education practices is perhaps the most obvious. In self-study, teacher educators do not have to position their own practice outside the boundaries of legitimate inquiry. The work of teaching teachers becomes a site of scholarship.
But self-study is not the only possibility. Practitioner inquiry. Action research. Scholarship of teaching and learning. Design-based approaches. Improvement inquiry. Collaborative professional inquiry. Different traditions offer different methodological possibilities. The broader principle matters more: Teacher educators should be able to build scholarly careers not only by producing knowledge about teacher education but also by producing, examining, improving, and sharing teacher education practice.
Universities increasingly use the language of impact. But our measures of impact remain heavily tied to academic circulation. Citations. Journal prestige. Grant dollars. Research reputation. Those things matter. They tell us whether scholarship enters scholarly conversations. But teacher education should have another question available: Did this work enter professional practice?
Suppose a research article receives fifty scholarly citations. Now suppose an open-access teacher education tool is used by 8,000 teacher educators, adapted by programs in several countries, incorporated into doctoral preparation, and reshapes how supervisors conduct conversations with candidates.
Which has more impact? That is the wrong question if it assumes one must defeat the other. They represent different forms of impact. The real problem arises when one has a clear place in our evaluation structures and the other sits in a category called “other.”
Faculty evaluation systems teach. They tell emerging scholars what kind of work matters. They tell doctoral students what an academic career requires. They tell junior faculty what deserves their limited time. They tell senior faculty where institutional prestige resides. So when we tell teacher educators that many creative and applied scholarly contributions are welcome but define satisfactory productivity through a narrow set of empirical journal articles, we send a message. The message is not that practice does not matter. It is subtler: Practice matters after you have secured the research products that count.
For a field devoted to teaching and teacher learning, that hierarchy deserves serious scrutiny. Because the consequence is not merely what appears in promotion dossiers. It shapes what teacher educators spend their careers doing.
Imagine doctoral students learning that part of becoming a teacher educator involves developing contributions to the practice of teacher education that are worth sharing.
Imagine new faculty being encouraged not only to establish research agendas but also to develop a pedagogy of teacher education worth examining.
Imagine experienced faculty documenting how their scholarship has changed supervision, mentoring, curriculum, partnerships, professional learning, or teacher educator development.
Imagine promotion committees asking not only how often someone's work has been cited, but where the work has traveled professionally.
Imagine podcasts, practitioner essays, curricula, tools, professional learning designs, and program innovations being evaluated seriously – not automatically credited, but seriously evaluated – for their intellectual and professional contribution.
Imagine asking every teacher educator two questions: What have you helped us understand about teacher education?, and What have you contributed to making teacher education better?
Neither should replace the other. But both should matter. If we place the empirical research product at the center and everything else at the margins, we should not be surprised when teacher educators become better rewarded for observing the profession than for advancing its practice.
Research about teaching matters enormously. But for teacher educators, scholarship should not require distance from the very practice we exist to understand and improve. A field devoted to teaching teachers should make room for its practice – not merely its study – to become serious scholarly work.
Boyer, E. L. (1990). Scholarship reconsidered: Priorities of the professoriate. Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching.
Glassick, C. E., Huber, M. T., & Maeroff, G. I. (1997). Scholarship assessed: Evaluation of the professoriate. Jossey-Bass.
Share ideas, ask questions, and learn with colleagues around the world.
Browse more stories